The history of artists boycotting Spotify can be split into two distinct eras. The first was defined by superstars making powerful but ultimately temporary statements. The second, unfolding now, is characterized by a less famous but more ideologically driven collective of indie artists who see their departure as final. This fundamental difference suggests the current movement may have a more lasting impact.
The first era saw icons like Taylor Swift and Thom Yorke pull their music in protest of low royalty rates. Later, Neil Young and Joni Mitchell left over Spotify’s exclusive deal with podcaster Joe Rogan. While these actions drew massive media attention and sparked important conversations, each of these artists eventually returned to the platform, tacitly acknowledging its immense power and reach in the industry.
The new era, however, is populated by artists for whom Spotify’s perceived flaws—from “royalty theft” to its founder’s ties to military AI—are not just business disputes but moral red lines. When a band like King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard leaves, they are not just negotiating; they are taking a stand. As professor Eric Drott explains, these artists are beginning to doubt the core promise of visibility, making the decision to leave less of a strategic risk.
This shift is also about a change in mindset. The earlier boycotts were largely individual actions. Today’s movement, centered around events like “Death to Spotify” and organized by groups like UMAW, is collaborative. It’s about building a shared alternative ecosystem, not just making a solitary point. The focus is on collective power and mutual support outside the mainstream system.
Ultimately, the first wave of boycotts exposed Spotify’s weaknesses, while the second wave is actively trying to build something to replace it. The quiet return of the superstars showed the platform’s resilience. The determined, and likely permanent, departure of a growing number of indie artists now tests its long-term cultural relevance and sustainability from the ground up.
6